Overall Ratings & Reviews Carnegie Hotel

We'll be staying here for all future NYC trips. Staff was great, place was great.

This is an absolute gem in the city. I couldn’t be life how reasonably it was priced at a prime location! The staff was top notch, especially Delia. She welcomed us so openly when we got into town earlier than check in time and held our bags. When our room was ready early, she texted us and then even confirmed we received her text when we arrived. Fantastic service! Paulo was also extremely kind and helpful. Breakfast in the morning was a great start to the day and we enjoyed the wine and cheese with friends in the evening. It was quite cold one day so I took advantage of the 24/7 tea/coffee/juice. Thank you for a wonderful experience and we will be sure to come back next time we are in the city!

Good basic hotel. Clean rooms. Small rooms. Good mattress. Nice coffee machine in lobby. Breakfast is basic but nice free option

Everything about this hotel is excellent for a business trip. Nice front staff, good location, nice room, everything's working, and I loooooove the free breakfast and snacks. It's not fancy, but the fact that they don't try make $30 extra on me from breakfast and/or a mini bar is really nice. Only slight downside was outside noise even though they have soundproof windows (I think). It's hard to avoid in NYC if your rooms is facing the street. But I'd come back any time.

Professional staff, clean rooms, 2 steps from Carnegie Hall, nice restaurants.

Great staff - very friendly. Fantastic location. Small rooms though

Five-day, four-night NY trip to visit museums. The room, though unexpectedly very small, was clean and up-to-date. Excellent bathroom and shower, Elderly guests would benefit from a higher sitting toilet. Queen bed was comfortable with good pillows, mini-fridge did not work. Maid service was good and unobtrusive. The free breakfast was very good; no need to buy breakfast out. Late afternoon free wine and snack offerings very good, also.The room was very quiet from outside noise, but was offset by elevator noise.This is my only big complaint. Got use to it after one day and used earplugs while sleeping, but usually quiet between 9:30pm to 7:00 am. All staff were very helpful and pleasant. Subway and bus access literally around the corner.

Nice hotel. Okay breakfast and nice afternoon wine party.

This quite new hotel has extremely thoughtful design, the best hotel pillows I have ever encountered, great staff and generous breakfasts and a daily afternoon wine reception included in the price - outstanding.

Great hotel and perfect location for seeing Broadway shows

It's a nice place to stay

Fabulous location in the heart of everything!

The hotel was in a great area, clean and the staff was very helpful and personable. Yolanda was very engaging. Will absolutely here on my next visit to NYC.

Great

I wish the room were more spacious. The rate seems overpriced given the size of both the room and the overall facility. However, the staff are kind and accommodating.

Loved our one night stay. Room was perfectly designed. Small but fully efficient, clean & comfortable. Excellent location & affordable.

If you want to be close to Central Park but still close to Midtown area, it is a great venue. Hotel is very clean, staff was very friendly.

Third time I have stayed here and never disappoints. Simple and clean hotel that is in a great location especially for music lovers. Staff is wonderful as well.

X

No lobby or atmosphere but staff was excellent and very clean facilities.